It’s that special time again—that blazin’ hot molten lava of a time—oh yes. It’s American Idol time…
Lil’ Archie is first up, and the most I can muster for this boy is a wholehearted ‘meh’. Billy Joel? Simon, of course, is secretly salivating at the thought of bringing out the entire Westlife back-catalogue for a whole new generation. Just think, ‘Flying Without Wings’—the junior years. Lil’ Archie in that powder blue suit, rising from his stool at the key change, spreading his arms wide with puppyish love and devotion…
Please, lord, no.
Syesha, on the other hand, they’re determined to send packing. Why else would they give her an Alicia Keyes song? Hell, if they gave Mariah Carey an Alicia Keyes song, she would end up sounding like a pale imitation, so poor Syesha does an awesome job just managing to sound half-way decent. She’s also brought out the gold sequins for like, the fourth week running, as if she’s decided that it’s not the voice, song choice or crazy obsessive fan factor that’s been pushing her through, oh no, it’s because she’s been DAZZLING them with her GOLDEN BRILLIANCE.

Which leads us to D. Cook, who I can’t help but like despite a) the hair, b) the facial fuzz and c) the oodles of smug. ‘The First Time Ever I Saw Your Face’. Honestly, the best thing for his long-term career would be to fail, and fail hard at this point, but here he is, doing his soft start/hard finish thing, but god, I wish he’d stop being so damn controlled! Lose it, freak out, just show some passion, boy, instead of the Scott Strapp school o’ messianic rock.
But that’s nothing, because oh. My. God. Lil’ Archie just said “My boo.” And “Lil’ mama”. And he’s bobbing! He’s swaying like it’s junior prom, and all with that fixed thousand-yard beam. This is bad, people. This is Jason Castro butchering Marley bad—the kind of cringefest that ensues when an awkward white boy tries to bring out reggae or hip hop or in this case, squeaky-clean chart r ‘n’ b, and shows how entirely without game he truly is.
Someone who has game, eons of it, is my girl Syesha. Silver sequins! This girl’s got range, y’all. And a chair. AND AWESOMENESS. The judges all despise her, obviously, for standing between them and an all-David, all-profit finale, and I understand that, I really do—I mean, what kind of fight can Syesha put up in a marketplace where even Nicole Scherpussycatzinger lies dejected in a heap of unwanted fishnets in the corner? But she’s a FIGHTER. With a CHAIR. And dude, I’d take her cabaret performance over the freaking cartoon Pinocchio bleating on, because despite all his protests to the contrary, he is so not a real boy.

Meanwhile, I’m too relieved that the rumors about Cook breaking out the Collective Soul are false to care that he’s replaced it with Switch-freaking-foot. And his voice is so… wrong. Wafty and wavery and surprise, it’s starting slow but FINALLY he gets some damn emotion in his delivery and then… It’s over. Huh. And Paula agrees with me? I’m scared. I’m not sure I want to be on the same wavelength as somebody traveling through time and space to an Idaho prom store in the late 80’s to buy their dresses.
And now it’s even worse because Lil’ Archie READ MY MIND. Powder blue shirt, stool, squinty emotion—and why the hell is Randy freaking out over that? But sheesh, the dullness! And when Simon complains about the saccharine-content of a performance, you know it’s bad, because people, this man inflicted ROBSON AND JEROME on the general British public.
Yup, they hate Syesha. ‘Hit Me Up’? I don’t even know this, but it’s totally a Lumidee/early Rhianna type jam and it’s so too much for her. The white sequins have diminished returns. Sad.

Umm. ‘I Don’t Want to Miss a Thing’. And Diane Warren is there to see the sacrilidge, with weirdly OTT production: violins and guitar and a METALLIC CRAVAT. Or is it an undershirt? Does it even matter? I mean, we all know he’s going to be a finalist, tied to a 19 Management contract and a debut album of syrupy Goo Goo Dolls cast-offs and regretting forever his choice to prostrate himself at the alter of American reality capitalism. So, metallic under-garments or not, dude is screwed.